Ethno::log
 :: Sonner la cloche anthropologique :: Ringing the anthropological bell ::
:: Die ethnologische Glocke läuten :: Tocar la campana antropológica ::

Question: 'Culture' As We Dont't Mean


The term 'culture' is definitly the most discussed term in anthropology. But the debate is always about the scientific meaning. In german (in english also?) there are also other meanings, which are not part of this debate, except to express, that we don't mean this meaning. The problem is, that if we have to talk about this 'external' meaning, we don't have a term for it. My question: Is there any term for culture as it's meant in daily life, expressing institutionalised culture like classical music, theater etc.? Bettina Beer describes it in the article "Ethnos, Ethnie, Kultur" (1)Beer, Bettina: Ethnos, Ethnie, Kultur. In: Fischer, Hans: Ethnologie. Berlin : Reimer, 2003, S. 60. "Kultur im Sinne von Kultur-behörde und Kultus-ministerium oder im Sinne des Feuilletons als Musik, Theater, Literatur, Architektur und bildende Kunst." A shorter term? My ideas:

  • bürgerliche Kulturverständnis
  • institutionalisierte Kultur Any other suggestions?

... Comment

first, I'm not sure whether it's possible to find a "scientific" meaning for "culture". Everything which is 'cultural' defies that kind of measurement and dry definition which is required for rigorous science. I think your question about the "external" meaning is just the very general thing that people outside academia sometimes use the same words as we do, but with quite different meaning. Notions like "culture", "society", "progress", "modernity" etc pp.
The difference with the use of such words in scholarly discourse is that the acdemics tries to think more thoroughly what they actually mean.
Regarding your "institutionalised culture", Bourdieu comes to my mind. I don't think that he uses the word "culture" a lot in his book "Distinction", but it is essentially about those modes of distinguishing oneself from others through "cultural capital". Habitus is the word. But those notions are, of course, not refering to "culture as it's meant in daily life". Besides, this notion of "high-culture vs low culture" to which you are refering (classical music, theater) is not the only way "ordinary" people use the word culture in their "daily" life. The "anthropological" sense of culture (as that thing which makes certain groups of people different, i.e. their language, customs, religion, rituals, etc), is also quite common for most people in our societies. Why are Chinese people so strange to us? It's not because of their biological characteristics - no, most of us liberals would say: it's kulcha.

... Link

Well, this was an long answer regarding the debate in anthropology, but without an answer regarding a better term. Interesting thing with bourdieu, so it would be wise not to use this term "institutionalisierte Kultur" as it could come to missunderstandings.

Other ideas?

... Link

on definitions of concepts ..

@vernant,
i agree.
descartes would have answered (in free translation): there exist terms that are only "not helpfully" defineable, which means, you actually can find a true and correct definition, but it wont be of that sort you can work with.
(the early anthropological definition of ´culture` by raymond williams: ´culture` as a whole way of life is another true and correct but not helpful definition.)

@kerleone,
the answer to what you are trying to clear up is ´context` - meaning both epistemological understanding as methodological acting.

edit: your terms "bürgerliche kultur" and "institutionalisierte kultur" refer to two different things: popculture or highculture (depending on context) and institutions and the latest scientific focus concerning institutionalized culture: mediators.

... Link


... Comment

The finest stuff from ethnology social/cultural anthropology and cyberanthropology. Collected with ceaseless endeavour by students and staff of the Institut für Ethnologie in München/Germany and countless others.
... about this website

Online for 8346 days
Last modified: 11/29/22, 8:56 PM
Search
Browse by Category
Status
Youre not logged in ... Login
Menu
... Home
... Tags

Calendar
May 2024
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031
December
Recent updates
*uh *d'oh ! Tnks
for not taking it down entirely anyway !! :-)
by orangemcm. (11/29/22, 8:56 PM)
Schade Oh, so bad! The
oldest anthropology blog is closing :(( It seems the whole...
by iglu01 (1/4/20, 4:05 PM)
-- Closed -- I think
it's time to close the weblog, it's already sleeping since...
by kerleone (12/29/19, 1:54 PM)
gelöscht gelöscht
by Timo Gerhardt (6/9/18, 1:57 PM)
Stellenausschreibung des Max-Planck-Instituts für ethnologische
Forschung. Bewerbungsfrist: 15.02.2017 Das Max-Planck-Institut für ethnologische Forschung sucht Doktoranden/Doktorandinnen...
by HatEl (1/31/17, 9:11 AM)
Ethnosymposium in Halle (Saale): Call
for Contribution – 14.-17. Mai 2015 Call for Contribution –...
by normanschraepel (2/9/15, 3:35 PM)
Bruno Latour: Kosmokoloss. Eine Tragikomödie
über das Klima Der Hörspiel Pool von Bayern 2 hat...
by pietzler (11/21/14, 3:23 PM)
Send us suggestions


Are you a Spammer (yes/no)?

FundraisingWhat is this for?