Ethno::log
 :: Sonner la cloche anthropologique :: Ringing the anthropological bell ::
:: Die ethnologische Glocke läuten :: Tocar la campana antropológica ::

Book Review: "Occidentalism"


"In 1978 Edward Said's landmark "Orientalism" did something that the vast majority of books, even great ones, fail to do: It literally changed the way we understand the world. By developing a system for conceiving and deconstructing the long and tangled relationship between East and West -- a relationship that Said argued was marked, throughout the colonial era, by the West's systematic portrayal of the East as culturally and racially primitive, exotic, backward and inferior -- Said virtually created an entirely new field, post-colonialism, which continues to have profound effects on academia and international politics to this day.

The new book "Occidentalism" expressly positions itself as the Western-looking counterpart to the Said classic. Its authors want us to believe that it, too, will shatter myths, define a new genre of thought and study, and change the way we understand the world." Read more at Salon.com (Requires watching a commercial for free day pass).


... Comment

had a look at that site, but couldn't find your book. I would appreciate if you could at least say who wrote it, when you recommend us a book, and give reference to reviews on other pages -

... Link

On the site was only the beginning of the article. You have to subscribe to salon.com OR watch a commercial for a free one day subscription.

Occidentalism: The West in the Eyes of Its Enemies
by Ian Buruma, Avishai Margalit

I could think that its heavily discussed at the moment in anthropology, but I am not in that topic. People in that topic didn't manage to get a nickname for ethno::log ;-)

8 hours ago Time Magazine published also an review.

... Link

CARRIER, JAMES G. 1992. Occidentalism. American Ethnologist 19(2): 195-212.

NADER, L. 1989. Orientalism, Occidentalism, and the Control of Women. Cultural Dynamics 2(3): 323-355.

... Link

Crouching Orientalism and Hidden Infamy

I just read the review in Time Magazine to which Kerleone has pointed. If it retells the core of the book correctly, then the book falls a bit short, IMHO. Because: The answer to the question "Why do they [the Arabs] hate us [the US-Americans]." is given on a purely intellectual level, a level of discourse, of ideas. The hands-on, real-world causes like US-American global interventions, both military and economic, are not mentioned at all. The argument 'the stereotypes out of which the Others construct their view of the Occident come from western discourses and history of ideas' hides another infamy: The Orientals are intellectually unable to generate their own stereotypes -- even those they have to borrow from the West. That may sound a bit far-fetched, but I am always reminded of the history lessons I had to receive at school. The succesful conquest of the Americas, especially by the spanish Conquistadores, was always attributed to the technological superiority of the Spaniards -- especially in respect to weaponry. Then, with a sigh of regret and sorrow, it was said, to what cruel use this superiority was put. But behind all this humanistic concernment always a stressing of the superiority was hidden -- at least it seems so from my vantage point.

Edit: I just realized the subtitle of Christopher John Farah's review of the book at Salon.com: "Occidentalism" offers a grand theory about why Arabs and Muslims feel the way they do about the West -- but ignores what the West has done to them."

Well said Mr. Farah, well said!

... Link


... Comment

The finest stuff from ethnology social/cultural anthropology and cyberanthropology. Collected with ceaseless endeavour by students and staff of the Institut für Ethnologie in München/Germany and countless others.
... about this website

Online for 8485 days
Last modified: 11/29/22, 8:56 PM
Search
Browse by Category
Status
Youre not logged in ... Login
Menu
... Home
... Tags

Calendar
September 2024
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
2930
December
Recent updates
*uh *d'oh ! Tnks
for not taking it down entirely anyway !! :-)
by orangemcm. (11/29/22, 8:56 PM)
Schade Oh, so bad! The
oldest anthropology blog is closing :(( It seems the whole...
by iglu01 (1/4/20, 4:05 PM)
-- Closed -- I think
it's time to close the weblog, it's already sleeping since...
by kerleone (12/29/19, 1:54 PM)
gelöscht gelöscht
by Timo Gerhardt (6/9/18, 1:57 PM)
Stellenausschreibung des Max-Planck-Instituts für ethnologische
Forschung. Bewerbungsfrist: 15.02.2017 Das Max-Planck-Institut für ethnologische Forschung sucht Doktoranden/Doktorandinnen...
by HatEl (1/31/17, 9:11 AM)
Ethnosymposium in Halle (Saale): Call
for Contribution – 14.-17. Mai 2015 Call for Contribution –...
by normanschraepel (2/9/15, 3:35 PM)
Bruno Latour: Kosmokoloss. Eine Tragikomödie
über das Klima Der Hörspiel Pool von Bayern 2 hat...
by pietzler (11/21/14, 3:23 PM)
Send us suggestions


Are you a Spammer (yes/no)?

FundraisingWhat is this for?